version sound wrote:Best American punk band of the '90s.
xxxMidgexxx wrote:But perhaps I just love drone stuff in general.
version sound wrote:Best American punk band of the '90s.
xxxMidgexxx wrote:But perhaps I just love drone stuff in general.
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
version sound wrote:Saying twice don't make it right.
Sweetbelly > Red Hare >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Jawbreaker (who weren't even a punk band)
xxxMidgexxx wrote:But perhaps I just love drone stuff in general.
JGJR wrote:version sound wrote:Saying twice don't make it right.
Sweetbelly > Red Hare >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Jawbreaker (who weren't even a punk band)
Have you ever actually heard Jawbreaker?
And sorry for the double post. I meant to edit and posted it again (not sure how).
JGJR wrote:version sound wrote:Saying twice don't make it right.
Sweetbelly > Red Hare >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Jawbreaker (who weren't even a punk band)
Have you ever actually heard Jawbreaker?
And sorry for the double post. I meant to edit and posted it again (not sure how).
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
gregpolard wrote:How is Jawbreaker (at least the pre-major label stuff) not a punk band? Have you ever listened to "Unfun"? It's a melodic punk rock record.
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
gregpolard wrote:How is Jawbreaker (at least the pre-major label stuff) not a punk band? Have you ever listened to "Unfun"? It's a melodic punk rock record.
xxxMidgexxx wrote:But perhaps I just love drone stuff in general.
gregpolard wrote:Do you consider the Buzzcocks a punk band? The Sex Pistols? The Ramones?
version sound wrote:gregpolard wrote:Do you consider the Buzzcocks a punk band? The Sex Pistols? The Ramones?
Contextually. If somone played that stuff for me and I had never heard it and knew nothing about the bands, I don't know if I'd call it punk. You guys have a lot more tolerance for melody in your punk than I do. Generally speaking, I do not like singing in punk. Melodic music is fine, but combine it with melodic vocals and you've lost me 9 times out of 10. I know a lot of you have a more big tent definition, but if punk cannot be defined in musical terms, then it just becomes a matter of fashion and association.
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
version sound wrote:I don't care who buys lunch, I'm not drinking the pop punk kool aid. Give me a reason that any of these bands are punk that doesn't rely mainly, if not solely, on the clothes they wore or the other bands they played with.
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
version sound wrote:gregpolard wrote:Do you consider the Buzzcocks a punk band? The Sex Pistols? The Ramones?
Contextually. If somone played that stuff for me and I had never heard it and knew nothing about the bands, I don't know if I'd call it punk. You guys have a lot more tolerance for melody in your punk than I do. Generally speaking, I do not like singing in punk. Melodic music is fine, but combine it with melodic vocals and you've lost me 9 times out of 10. I know a lot of you have a more big tent definition, but if punk cannot be defined in musical terms, then it just becomes a matter of fashion and association.
version sound wrote:I should have learned by now that Dag Nasty fans have no taste. The fact that most of you prefer Dag to ROS should have really cemented that in my mind.
version sound wrote:Definitions change. Ask a kid what emo is and he sure as fuck won't reference the Revolution Summer. He'll probably also tell you that Avril is punk. In short, all is lost, and you '90s pop punkers are largely to blame.
I'm also pretty sure that the Sex Pistols and Ramones didn't self-identify as "punk". Punk is 99% individual perception.
version sound wrote:I do consider the Sex Pistols a punk band. My point was that, free of context, most people would consider the music they made plain old hard rock. There isn't anything intrinsically more "punk" about their music than AC/DC's.
BAIN wrote:version sound wrote:I do consider the Sex Pistols a punk band. My point was that, free of context, most people would consider the music they made plain old hard rock. There isn't anything intrinsically more "punk" about their music than AC/DC's.
time for everyone to walk away from this troll thread
jaybird wrote:BAIN wrote:version sound wrote:I do consider the Sex Pistols a punk band. My point was that, free of context, most people would consider the music they made plain old hard rock. There isn't anything intrinsically more "punk" about their music than AC/DC's.
time for everyone to walk away from this troll thread
Yeah, I started typing out a reply, but then I remembered arguing about the definition of "punk" was stupid 25 years ago in the MRR letters section.
version sound wrote:jaybird wrote:BAIN wrote:version sound wrote:I do consider the Sex Pistols a punk band. My point was that, free of context, most people would consider the music they made plain old hard rock. There isn't anything intrinsically more "punk" about their music than AC/DC's.
time for everyone to walk away from this troll thread
Yeah, I started typing out a reply, but then I remembered arguing about the definition of "punk" was stupid 25 years ago in the MRR letters section.
I didn't start the fucking argument. I don't think of Jawbreaker as punk. End of story. There doesn't need to be an argument, you guys can just accept that as my opinion/perception. I didn't argue when you claimed SF weren't punk. I don't really care how you care to classify them. This thread was meant to be a celebration of SF. If you don't like them, good for you. Very early on, I said, punk or not, I prefer SF to Jawbreaker. You guys were the ones who jumped in to defend their punkness. I don't care one way or the other what you guys consider punk.
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
version sound wrote:They talk about All and the Descendents a whole lot.
version sound wrote:What's the ETA for that new Dorkboard? Greg, you'd like it there. They talk about All and the Descendents a whole lot.
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
jaybird wrote:version sound wrote:They talk about All and the Descendents a whole lot.
Nah, not really. we mostly make fun of a retarded 40 year-old and tell each other what we had for lunch.
jaybird wrote:version sound wrote:They talk about All and the Descendents a whole lot.
Nah, not really. we mostly make fun of a retarded 40 year-old and tell each other what we had for lunch.
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
version sound wrote:jaybird wrote:version sound wrote:They talk about All and the Descendents a whole lot.
Nah, not really. we mostly make fun of a retarded 40 year-old and tell each other what we had for lunch.
I refuse to be your Dorian, but wouldn't mind hearing about your lunch.
jaybird wrote:Left over pot roast w/carrots, onions, potatoes & celery.
2 clementines
1 apple
water
xxxHunterxxx wrote:I refuse to believe Dorian is real. Nobody could lack self-awareness to that extent.
Welly wrote:If you're comparing the punk-ness of Sweetbelly Freakdown to Jawbreaker it's a fallacy.
In correct context Sweetbelly Freakdown should be compared and contrasted with Jets to Brazil of the same time, which was outright emo navel-gazing indie dull coma music.
I wasn't really into Sweetbelly Freakdown either, but it was definitely more punk than Jets to Snoozeville. I preferred Jesuseater if anything.
Jawbreaker was definitely punk. Now shut it.
scannest wrote:It's like a filmmaker saying "Spielberg is my idol. Every time I get behind the camera I think about how I can make my film as good as Hook"
gregpolard wrote:Jets didn't age as well for me as I'd have liked. The first album is cool.
version sound wrote:I'm curious why people who love Swiz dismiss Sweetbelly so often. I don't really understand why you would love one and not the other. I don't think the two are markedly different. I love Jesuseater too. And Red Hare. And Dag with Shawn.
jaybird wrote:xxxHunterxxx wrote:I refuse to believe Dorian is real. Nobody could lack self-awareness to that extent.
I have met him in person. He's the real deal.
Welly wrote:version sound wrote:I'm curious why people who love Swiz dismiss Sweetbelly so often. I don't really understand why you would love one and not the other. I don't think the two are markedly different. I love Jesuseater too. And Red Hare. And Dag with Shawn.
It just didn't chime with me at the time, maybe I should re-visit it.
xxxHunterxxx wrote:jaybird wrote:xxxHunterxxx wrote:I refuse to believe Dorian is real. Nobody could lack self-awareness to that extent.
I have met him in person. He's the real deal.
Is he better in person than on the Internets?
BAIN wrote:version sound wrote:I should have learned by now that Dag Nasty fans have no taste. The fact that most of you prefer Dag to ROS should have really cemented that in my mind.
Sweetbelly Freakdown is so far from punk it isn't funny. I would almost want to lump them with shitty nyhc bands.
This is right on the mark...jaybird wrote:version sound wrote:gregpolard wrote:Do you consider the Buzzcocks a punk band? The Sex Pistols? The Ramones?
Contextually. If somone played that stuff for me and I had never heard it and knew nothing about the bands, I don't know if I'd call it punk. You guys have a lot more tolerance for melody in your punk than I do. Generally speaking, I do not like singing in punk. Melodic music is fine, but combine it with melodic vocals and you've lost me 9 times out of 10. I know a lot of you have a more big tent definition, but if punk cannot be defined in musical terms, then it just becomes a matter of fashion and association.
If we're going to be this particular about the definition of "punk", I don't see how an obscure band like SF that was active 20 years after the initial punk explosion somehow has greater claim to the label than bands like The Sex Pistols or the Buzzcocks the Ramones, who were, you know, among the first and most widely-acclaimed bands to ever be classified under that label, and were the bands who the term was originally invented for.
But that's just me.
Welly wrote:If you're comparing the punk-ness of Sweetbelly Freakdown to Jawbreaker it's a fallacy.
In correct context Sweetbelly Freakdown should be compared and contrasted with Jets to Brazil of the same time, which was outright emo navel-gazing indie dull coma music.
I wasn't really into Sweetbelly Freakdown either, but it was definitely more punk than Jets to Snoozeville. I preferred Jesuseater if anything.
Jawbreaker was definitely punk. Now shut it.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 73 guests