Madonna vs. Cyndi Lauper

[version sound]

Overall, Madge, but "Time After Time" is the best thing either ever did.

[The Snake]

Girls Just Want To Have Fun, She Bop, True colors and Time After Time are better than most of the stuff that Madonna ever did.

[jaybird]

Overall, Madge, but "Time After Time" is the best thing either ever did.

False:

[77clash]

I'm going with Madonna and her early singles.

[FormerLurker]

Did Cyndi do "Live to Tell"? No? There's your answer.

Now fuck off.

[jaybird]

Did Cyndi do "Live to Tell"? No? There's your answer.

Now fuck off.

[xxxMidgexxx]

Madge for Midge

[WrEtcH]

Overall, Madge, but "Time After Time" is the best thing either ever did.

"true colors" was great too. I go with Madge too. fave song "Angel"

[Hal]

Madonna looked better naked. But, musically, Cyndi wins for sure.

[the mean]

Cyndi. Not even close.

[clash77]

I just bought the "Like a Virgin" single from Welly..Solid record!!

[dave123]

Madonna has Cyndi beat on breadth of solid stuff, but Cyndi's hits are not to be ignored.

[kel]

Madonna kinda seemed like an old whore from day one. Then went dancey euro trash.


Go hit this YouTube vid and tell me this isn't a punk rock song. Rocks.

http://youtu.be/202o_JS7E04

[obik]

Go hit this YouTube vid and tell me this isn't a punk rock song. Rocks.

http://youtu.be/202o_JS7E04

That isn't a punk rock song.

[clash77]

Madonna kinda seemed like an old whore from day one. Then went dancey euro trash.


Go hit this YouTube vid and tell merate this isn't a punk rock song. Rocks.

http://youtu.be/202o_JS7E04

Castrate yourself..please..then you'll feel more comfortable.

[Welly]

I just bought the "Like a Virgin" single from Welly..Solid record!!

You only ever did rummage through the bargain box in my shop ya skinflint bastard.

Psycho's version is better. And that's saying something.

[clash77]

I just bought the "Like a Virgin" single from Welly..Solid record!!

You only ever did rummage through the bargain box in my shop ya skinflint bastard.

Psycho's version is better. And that's saying something.

Haha fucker..Where else would I expect to find that record?

[77clash]

the drum kit is too big to be punk rock

[JGJR]

Overall, Madge, but "Time After Time" is the best thing either ever did.

This.

[lewdd]

I remember the time when Cyndi was managed by Captain Lou Albano.

[jason powell]

Madonna, easily. Lauper is great too, but, I always hated the interviews she had where she keeps talking about how unusual she is as if thats not the same thing her album is called. Plus, Madonna toured with the Beastie Boys.

[JGJR]

Madonna, easily. Lauper is great too, but, I always hated the interviews she had where she keeps talking about how unusual she is as if thats not the same thing her album is called. Plus, Madonna toured with the Beastie Boys.

And was part of the NYC post-punk scene, hung out with Ike Yard, lived in the same apartment building (or the one next to it) in the East Village that I used to visit a really good friend at in the mid to late '90s, etc.

[john stabb]

The Plusses:

Madonna for early days of hanging with NYC crowd.
Cyndi for hanging with Lou Albano.
Madonna for great debut album.
Cyndi for "Time after Time".
Madonna for time with Sean Penn.
Cyndi for swallowing a bug accidentally in concert but not making huge deal of it.
Madonna for looking hot as brunette in Live Aid.

The Minuses:

Cyndi for annoying songs on video like "Girls just wanna have fun".
Madonna for annoying songs on video like "Vogue".
Cyndi for awful jazz singing.
Madonna for not trying to push drunken Courtney off roof during crashing of MTV interview.
Cyndi for that cartoon voice.
Madonna for trying to work her way into young audiences graces by kissing Brittney on TV.
Madonna for attempting to act.
Madonna for attempting to write children's book.
Madonna for (again) trying to work her way into young audiences graces dry humping Miley Cyrus on TV.

Tough to choose ...

[The Snake]

Only plus for Madonna is that Joe Foster (Unity/Ignite/Speak 714) danced in one of her video (I think it was Vogue).

[Welly]

The Plusses:

Two different shades of the same shit.

The Minuses:

Two different shades of the same shit.

Tough to choose...